Old Version
Economy

Waste of Space

As China has expanded capacity to handle urban waste and divert trash from landfills, overcapacity in waste-to-energy plants has left some regions scrabbling for garbage

By Chen Weishan Updated Nov.1

People watch as a giant claw moves trash at a waste-to-energy plant, Nanchang, Jiangxi Province, June 29, 2024 (Photo by IC)

From once being reliant on enormous landfills to dispose of mountains of urban waste, China has turned to incineration as the preferred method of disposal, which in turn generates energy. But alongside the rush to build waste-to-energy (WtE) plants comes another issue – not enough trash to power the incinerators.  

In June, China’s Ministry of Ecology and Environment (MEE) released the 2024 Bulletin on the State of China’s Ecological Environment. Preliminary estimates show that the total amount of urban household waste removed in 2024 stood at 262.4 million tons, equivalent to approximately 718,800 tons removed daily. However, the total daily processing capacity for urban household waste across the country has reached 1.2 million tons. The severe overcapacity in waste incineration has led to a bizarre phenomenon: several cities and counties are scrambling for waste from other regions, and some have even resorted to excavating landfills. 

Statistics from the Ministry of Housing and Urban-Rural Development and the MEE show there were only 67 waste incineration plants nationwide in 2005, while in October 2024, there were at least 1,010. In 2023, more than 78 percent of waste was being incinerated, while only 13 percent was disposed of in landfill, The Paper reported.  

Domestic waste incineration plants are densely concentrated in China’s developed southeastern regions. Most of these plants began operating in the past decade. Once regarded as an effective solution to the garbage mountains at landfills, they have now created new troubles. 

Burning Out 
During an inspection of waste facilities in Henan Province in July 2021, the Ministry of Ecology and Environment reported that some new WtE plants were operating well below capacity, with one in the city of Hebi operating at just 50 percent capacity. In response, the following year Hebi authorities redirected all household waste from surrounding counties and townships under its jurisdiction to the city’s Qibi District facility. It even transferred 90,000 tons of waste from its neighbor, Anyang, and began to excavate landfills, unearthing 91,000 tons of aged waste to make up for the shortfall. In 2021, Jinhua, Zhejiang Province started planning to excavate and incinerate 260,000 tons of aged waste to tackle the urgent garbage shortage.  

The most glaring sign is the widespread shutdown of incinerators. According to research by the E20 Institute, an environment industry think tank, the average operating rate of China’s waste incineration plants stands at around 60 percent, with 40 percent of capacity remaining idle, resulting in uneven operational performance. Pan Gong, director of the Solid Waste Industry Research Center at the E20 Institute and chief industry analyst, told NewsChina that the excessive construction of WtE incinerators in the last decade is behind the decline in the amount of waste handled by each plant, not the lack of waste.  

Pan said that at the peak for constructing WtE plants, an average of 103 new incinerators were commissioned annually from 2017 to 2021. Because of the time lag between construction and operation, the overcapacity issue only became evident in 2022.  

A recent analysis by The Paper studied the operational status of waste incineration furnaces through the monitoring platform for WtE plants, the National Online Platform for Waste-to-Energy Plant Monitoring Data. It found daily processing capacity of waste incinerators increased from 238,000 tons in 2016 to 1.17 million tons in 2024. This also led to incineration surpassing landfills in 2020, becoming the primary way to handle urban domestic waste. In 2023, 78.3 percent of urban domestic waste was incinerated, while the proportion of waste going to landfill dropped to 13.2 percent.  

While the overall load rate of waste incineration plants remains low, not all plants are short of garbage.  

Zhang Jingning, head of the incineration project at the Wuhu Ecological Environment Protection Volunteers Association in Anhui Province, told NewsChina that while overall data indicates a general surplus in domestic waste incineration capacity, there are distinctive regional disparities. Waste incineration plants in some major cities operate at relatively saturated load rates, whereas in smaller cities, waste incinerators run at around 50 percent capacity. Citing Weinan, Shaanxi Province as an example, Zhang said that the city’s six incinerators are competing for garbage. However, in some counties, there is not enough incineration capacity.  

Zhang said that some local enterprises piloted small waste incinerators with a daily processing capacity of 300 tons. However, due to the difficulty of collecting, transporting and processing waste in some counties, especially large mountainous areas, enthusiasm waned, even though these areas still need waste incinerators. Some industry insiders told NewsChina that overcapacity is due to local government decisions. 

A green energy company employee explains how waste is used to generate power to a group of students on a tour of a plant, Taizhou, Jiangsu Province, August 2023 (Photo by VCG)

What Rubbish? 
According to Xue Tao, deputy director of the E20 Institute, the sharp growth in domestic waste incineration capacity started in the early 2000s, when the government transferred responsibility for waste incineration to franchise operations and promoted the build-operate-transfer (BOT) model for WtE plants. Under the BOT model, the government awards projects to private enterprises for construction, operation and management, with ownership eventually transferring back to the government after a specified period, usually 25 to 40 years.  

Around 2008, the number of waste incineration plants under construction began to rise, growing from a single-digit annual count to over a dozen.  

“All stakeholders gradually recognized the advantages of developing WtE plants via the franchise model. On one hand, it required no government funding, on the other hand, the projects made money through power generation coupled with State subsidies. So both governments and enterprises were eager to advance WtE projects,” Xue said.  

In Xue’s view, the franchise system is a driver of the excessive construction of WtE plants. “Local district and county governments can push forward franchise projects within their own administrative jurisdiction,” he said, adding that it leads to hasty decision making.  

In 2006, enhanced subsidies were introduced for renewable energy power generation projects, making waste incineration power generation more lucrative. That year, the National Development and Reform Commission categorized WtE as biomass power generation, which is considered as renewable energy. It stipulated that the subsidized electricity price standard should be 0.25 yuan (3.5 US cents) per kilowatt-hour, a fixed tariff lasting for 15 years.  

According to Xue Tao, as waste incineration technologies and business models matured, private enterprises started investing in and building projects around 2010, a trend that was followed by Stateowned enterprises (SOEs), particularly in some provincial capitals.  

“This rush by SOEs into the sector to some extent exacerbated WtE overcapacity,” he noted.  

Construction of WtE plants continued to surge until 2020, when the State began to reduce renewable energy subsidies. Starting from January 1, 2021, WtE projects that had been approved but not yet commenced, as well as newly approved ones, would no longer be eligible for national subsidies. Industry insiders told reporters that this prompted many projects to “rush to break ground and accelerate construction” before the national subsidy window closed.  

In Pan Gong’s view, a more critical factor behind overcapacity is building too big and not in the right places, especially as populations are declining in some areas, such as rust belt cities in the northeast. “This arises from overly optimistic projections about future population growth and increases in per capita waste generation. However, currently, some cities’ ability to attract population is declining. Additionally, as social civility improves, per capita waste generation has also decreased. What’s more, project distribution lacks overall planning. For instance, some cities failed to consider transportation distances when first constructing plants,” Pan said.  

The effective enforcement of waste sorting policies in major cities is another factor. Major cities began rolling out neighborhood trash sorting schemes in July 2019, starting in Shanghai.  

Statistics indicate that in the first five months of 2025, the average daily amount of sorted recyclables in Shanghai reached 7,927 tons, with hazardous waste at two tons and household food waste at 8,690 tons. Compared to the first half of 2019, these figures have risen by 1.96 times, 13.6 times and 0.59 times, respectively. The volume of sorted household food waste accounted for roughly 35 percent of the total dry and wet waste. Instead of being sent to waste incineration plants, household food waste is converted into biogas via anaerobic digestion.  

Pan noted that as household food waste treatment facilities have been built nationwide, waste that would otherwise have been sent to incineration plants is being diverted. 

A waste incineration plant, Shiyan, Hubei Province, October 21, 2024 (Photo by VCG)

Power Moves 
The waste incineration industry is taking some measures to survive, such as burning industrial waste or excavating stockpiles of landfills.  

Pan believes that in addition to securing more waste for incineration, the power generation revenue of WtE plants will continue to grow as a result of technological advances and enhanced operational capabilities. “For instance, five years ago, incinerating one ton of waste generated approximately 300 kWh of electricity, whereas some plants now can reach up to 500 to 600 kWh. This is linked to factors such as technology, scale and the calorific value of waste,” he said. 

In addition, with the phasing out of national subsidies, the bidding price for waste disposal fees at waste incineration plants has increased, rising from 69 yuan (US$10) per ton during the 13th Five-Year Plan (2016-2020) to 99 yuan (US$14) per ton during the 14th Five-Year Plan (2021-2025).  

An industry insider speaking on condition of anonymity told NewsChina that compared to the decline in the amount of waste acquired by incineration plants, waste incineration enterprises are more troubled by government arrears. “Even with a capacity utilization rate of only 60 percent, enterprises can still break even, almost no project has suffered losses due to insufficient waste entering the plant,” the source said.  

However, government defaults on subsidies and waste disposal fees have been directly impacting enterprises’ cash flow, especially over the past few years. “Particularly in the past two to three years, local governments have begun defaulting on waste disposal fees. Currently, medium and large-scale waste incineration plants can cover variable costs such as labor and consumables for daily operations through power generation, but they can hardly recover their investments,” the source added.  

After years of development, the waste incineration industry has gradually moved from the frenzy of previous years back to rationality. Xue Tao noted that few new waste incineration projects are being built now, especially large-scale plants with a daily disposal capacity of more than 500 tons.  

Since urban waste sorting is now the norm, WtE plants need to adapt. Zhang Jingning believes they must seek new opportunities within the broader urban waste management system, rather than simply relying on incinerating domestic waste.  

One factor is the increased calorific value of incoming waste, achieved through better waste sorting and removal of wet waste, which boosts the quality of fuel, coupled with more ways to increase power generation.  

“They can develop other waste treatment sectors to create synergies with incineration plants, by building urban circular economy industrial parks, and they can expand into [taking over] waste collection and transportation links. This would also allow incineration plants to improve the quality of incoming waste. Additionally, they can engage in diversified operations. Beyond power generation, they can convert electricity into other products to sell [like heat supply],” Zhang said.

Print