Old Version
Society

Man vs Wild

After a wild tiger was trapped in a village as it searched for food, authorities and conservationists have opposing views on what is best for the big cat’s welfare, and how to proceed in future as humans encroach on more wild habitat

By Hu Kefei Updated Jul.1

Tigers roughhouse at a breeding center in Mudanjiang, Heilongjiang Province, July 29, 2020

Conservationists and authorities are in disagreement about what to do with a wild Amur tiger, who after finding himself in a village on April 23, pounced on a car with two occupants, who were shaken up, but not injured, and then attacked a farm worker, who suffered minor injuries. The juvenile male, apparently in just as much panic as the residents of Linhu Village, Mishan City in the northeastern Heilongjiang Province, tried to flee, as did the villagers. A video clip online shows a man and a woman in the car shouting “run, run” as they tried to drive away. The livestreamed tiger incident caused a sensation.  

A drone was used to find the endangered tiger as workers from local forestry departments attempted to trap it. Cornered near a farmhouse, the tiger became more and more agitated. He was finally darted with three tranquilizer pellets, and transferred to Heilongjiang Amur Tiger Park in Mudanjiang for assessment and examination.  

NewsChina learned from authorities in Heilongjiang Province that the big cat is a 2 to 3-year-old male, weighing 225 kilograms. They said the Amur tiger, also known as a Siberian tiger, will be quarantined for 45 days before being returned to the wild. On April 26, Heilongjiang Provincial Forestry and Grassland Bureau said at a press conference that “the appearance of the tiger fully shows that the ecological environment of Heilongjiang Province is improving and is more suitable for the Amur tiger and Amur leopard to inhabit and reproduce here.”  

Improved Environment? 
Song Dazhao, founder of the Chinese Felid Conservation Alliance (CFCA), a non-profit NGO, told NewsChina in late April that the presence of wild Amur tigers near areas of human habitation does not mean the environment is getting better. In fact, it might indicate the opposite, as increasingly constrained by human exploitation of the wilderness, they are forced to enter human habitats.  

Tigers, Song said, are vigilant and good at hiding. As human encroachment advances, the number of wild tigers globally declined to around 3,000. There are thought to be around 500 Amur tigers in the wild, and under 30 in China, due to poaching, Chinese media reported. A normal, healthy wild tiger will naturally avoid conflict, unless it is forced into proximity with people due to dwindling habitat.  

In Russia, a female Amur tiger’s range is about 224 to 414 square kilometers, while a male tiger needs about 800 to 1,000 square kilometers. Even if an adult tiger has an established range, the size of the territory means it is hard to avoid human contact.  

Zhou Haixiang, a member of the Chinese National Committee for the Man and the Biosphere Program, told NewsChina that it was likely the tiger entered northeastern China from Russia along the west side of Xingkai Lake, where the border with Russia is only a barbed wire fence. There have been sightings of tigers in that area, so Zhou guessed it was following prey.  

“The tiger came over and found that there was not a lot of food available, and there were villages, people and cars, which it finds terrifying. If it tried to go north to the Wanda Mountains, it would be blocked by the highway. In northeastern China, the mountains have been fragmented by highway networks with no consideration of building passages for wildlife movement,” Zhou said. “On many occasions, as highways were built, wild Amur tigers were trapped or died alone because they could not mate. Therefore, we can hardly conclude [this tiger sighting] is a sign of improving ecology.”  

Song agrees with Zhou. “It’s unlikely the tiger has already established a territory because it would normally stop in areas where there are human activities.” Song believes the tiger might have been looking for an appropriate habitat. The animal is still young and is able to support itself in the wild, but it may have been attracted to the village by the livestock.  

'Arrogant' Humans 
Shen Zhijun, director of Hongshan Zoo in Nanjing, Jiangsu Province, feels disheartened over the tiger incident. “It was a mistake, all a mistake, from the very moment people spotted the tiger, people took the wrong actions. We human beings should not be so arrogant.”  

The live media reports, drone activity and people running around surely combined to stress the tiger even more, he said.  

“The appearance of a wild tiger is a good sign of a wild population whether the environment has improved or not, but the media stirred up a sensation among the public, who felt the tiger should not invade human territory, or not even exist at all,” Shen said. “The idea of peaceful coexistence between humans and wildlife was shattered in a moment.”  

“After it attacked the people and the car, it didn’t continue, but instead retreated. This proves it’s wild and not an [escaped] captive one, since it panicked, an apparent stress response due to fear. The tiger showed far more fear than the villagers,” Zhou said.  

In Shen’s view, people should have been evacuated when the tiger appeared to prevent conflict. Then it could either peacefully leave or be humanely captured if there was no other option. The livestream coverage showed the situation was chaotic. Some netizens who viewed the footage commented that because it had attacked people, it should be killed. The responses to the cornered tiger saddened Shen.  

After it was shot by the first tranquilizer dart, the tiger roared and jumped out from its hiding place behind the house. Then it hid again.  

“A tiger doesn’t manifest fear by shaking or running out of control. When he was trying to escape and hide, it meant he wanted to leave, but the people on site didn’t give him the chance,” Song Dazhao said.  

“Having missed the initial opportunity to deal with him properly, capture becomes the least-worst solution, or at least better than shooting and killing it,” Song added.  

But the media circus and close-up filming with no consideration for what was a safe distance indicates the lack of professionalism.  

An animal protection worker tracks wild tigers in an animal conservation zone in Heilongjiang Province, July 8, 2020

Quarantine vs Release 
After capture, the tiger was named Wanda Mountain No.1 and sent to quarantine for 45 days at Heilongjiang Amur Tiger Park. The forestry bureau said its health and behavior would be observed, and assured media they would release it. 

“I just don’t understand why it has to wait 45 days before release ,” Shen Zhijun said. “The purpose of the rescue is to return it to the wild after a full checkup. It should be released as quickly as possible. As the tiger has no health problems, the longer it is in captivity, the harder it will be to survive in the wild in the future.”  

Liu Dan, chief engineer with Heilongjiang Amur Tiger Park, told media that the quarantine was intended to ensure the tiger was not suffering from highly pathogenic avian influenza, rabies, cat plague, parasites or other diseases.  

“Forty-five days is too long and wild animals would generate trust or hatred that they should never have, which then will lead to behavioral changes. They will be more daring in approaching humans,” Shen said.  

“Every living individual has a special ecological value to the environment, not to mention the tiger at the top of the food chain, which belongs only to nature. At present, against the backdrop of Earth’s dwindling species and fragile ecological chain, saving and releasing these wild animals are ways to repair the fragile ecosystem,” he said.  

“If we rescue a night heron or a turtledove, we will release them. Just recently, our zoo released some raptors such as the black eagle and Eurasian eagle-owl, although we know we can attract more visitors if we display such endangered species. After we assessed they could survive in the wild, we released them immediately. Why does the tiger need 45 days?” Shen said.  

Chen Yuelong, a technician at a wildlife rescue center with Hongshan Zoo in Nanjing, told NewsChina that based on his extensive experience, the process for wildlife rescue is “physical examination, observation, treatment, rehabilitation, physical examination, evaluation and release.”  

The principle is that release should happen as soon as possible if it is safe to do so and the wildlife meets the requirements, said Chen.  

Addressing concerns over whether the tiger would attack people again, Song Dazhao said that except in some rare cases, most tigers do not develop the habit of attacking people. “The tiger’s attack on people in Mishan was not for hunting, but it could attack again if people disturb it like they did this time.”  

“But these 45 days could increase the likelihood of it attacking people again as it will become habituated to humans providing food. So it may have a different reaction to meeting humans in the wild,” Zhou said.  

“As long as the rescue and feeding measures are scientific, even if the tiger is in captivity for 45 days, it can still be released without becoming dependent on humans. But the process for rescue and feeding should proceed with caution. They should keep the tiger in isolation and prevent it from seeing humans when given food,” Chen Yuelong said.  

“It was taken from the wild and it’s not accustomed to these living conditions and isolation. So the park must ensure it doesn’t become too stressed and remains psychologically stable,” Bao Weidong, Associate Professor of Zoology, School of Bioscience and Technology at Beijing Forestry University, told China Central Television (CCTV). He emphasized the need to keep the tiger isolated to allow it to return to the wild and not be affected by human interaction.  

Although authorities had not confirmed as of press time when they will release the tiger or where, Song Dazhao believes he should be released in a reserve or forest where there is no competition from another male tiger.  

The Amur Tiger Park must also provide an open evaluation of the tiger’s condition and make its conclusion in accord with current best practice.  

As China continues to increase protection for animals like tigers, there are sure to be more incidents as their numbers increase. Coexisting with tigers will become a vital issue that residents of wild tiger habitats must address. Experts interviewed by NewsChina indicated that a combined system of early warning, rescue and preventive mechanisms should be established to prevent other incidents like these. 

A video clip of the captured wild Amur tiger that was named Wanda Mountain No.1, Linhu Village, Heilongjiang Province, April 23, 2021

Print